Taking the tonic apart
In 2005 Dave Arnold realised he would never be satisfied with a traditional G&T. Carbonation is an ingredient, so he had to master it, to separate the volume of tonic from the amount of bubbles, and then rebuild the drink from first principles. Tonic water is water, sweetener (usually high-fructose corn syrup in the U.S.), citric acid, quinine sulfate and “flavors”. Many people think it is non-sweet and non-caloric like seltzer; in fact it is as sweet as soda, typically 9.5 to 10 percent sugar by weight. He likes tonic and does not want to reinvent it, only to make it hyper-fresh, hyper-crisp, crystal clear and impeccably clean, the second most refreshing drink in the world after seltzer.
Quinine
Quinine, the intensely bitter plant alkaloid that sets tonic apart from other lemon-lime sodas, fluoresces under UV light. It comes from the bark of the South American cinchona tree, used as medicine in Bolivia and Peru long before records, and since the sixteenth century by Europeans against malaria. Unlike many herbal remedies it is a real drug. In the mid-nineteenth century people found that small regular doses protected against malaria, and tonic water was born. Today’s tonic has too little to protect, though in malarial countries such as Senegal, he saw people drink it hoping to avoid the disease. An effective daily dose is around 0.3 gram of quinine sulfate, and the U.S. limit in tonic is 85 mg per litre, so protection would take 3.5 litres; commercial tonics usually contain much less than the limit.
Cinchona bark decoctions are brown and cloudy even after filtering, which would not do for a crystal-clear drink, and bark brings non-quinine flavours, so he wanted the pure compound. That was hard to get. It used to be sold over the counter for night leg cramps until 1994, and prescribed by doctors, but his mother, a doctor, refused firmly, citing the ethics and the risk. Too much quinine causes cinchonism, from nausea and dizziness to temporary deafness and blindness and, at worst, death from cardiac or kidney failure. Luckily it is so bitter that accidental overdose is nearly impossible if used properly. He bought it from a chemical supplier, with the warning that a chemical for food or drink must be USP, food grade or equivalent, because lower grades can contain dangerous impurities. USP quinine sulfate is costly: about $100 for 10 grams and nearly $500 for 100 grams when he wrote.
Quinine safety
Never let anyone who isn’t aware of the safety concerns work with quinine.
- As little as a third of a gram, the old malaria dose, can cause mild cinchonism in some people.
- Quinine must be diluted before it is consumed. He pre-dilutes into a syrup and weighs with a scale accurate to a hundredth of a gram; without one, you have no business working with quinine.
- Never use undiluted quinine powder: the amount for a single drink is vanishingly small and hard to measure. It also clumps and dissolves poorly, and clumps that miss your tongue give no warning of an overdose. Check any syrup that all the quinine has dissolved and pour it through a fine strainer.
Quinine Simple Syrup
Makes 1 litre. Weigh 0.5 gram of USP quinine sulfate into a small, bone-dry, non-stick, static-free container, so none sticks, and put the rest away where nobody will touch it. Weigh 615 grams of water and 615 grams of sugar and mix until the sugar is completely dissolved; by weight, this gives 1 litre of syrup. Add the syrup to a blender and add the quinine while it runs, blend about a minute at medium speed and let the bubbles clear. It should be clear with no specks; if you see white powder, blend more. Strain through a fine strainer into a container.
Make it as written before changing it. If too bitter, dilute with plain simple syrup rather than using less quinine, since under 0.5 gram is tricky to dose in a bar. If too mild, you have a harder problem: half a gram per litre of 1:1 syrup is about the solubility limit, and weaker syrups spoil faster. That limit is a safety feature. A litre of tonic at 10 percent sugar uses 170 ml (208 grams) of this syrup and so 0.069 gram of quinine, below the legal 0.083 gram, and to approach the limit you would need tonic of nearly 13 percent sugar, undrinkably sweet.
Cinchona Syrup (1.2 litres) avoids quinine: simmer 20 grams of powdered cinchona bark (about 3 tablespoons; grind chips if you cannot find powder) in 750 ml of filtered water for 5 minutes, cool, strain through a fine strainer and then a coffee filter, pressing on the bark (or centrifuge it), top up to 750 ml and blend in 750 grams of sugar. It is brown and less clear.
He also notes the claim online that commercial quinine is synthetic. He found no credible source, and everything he read says extraction from cinchona bark is still the cheapest way.
The lime and the acid
Tonic also has citric acid and flavours that taste to him just of lime, and the weak citrus is one of his gripes. In 2006 he could not carbonate juice, so he distilled the flavour of fresh limes at room temperature in a home-made rotary evaporator, then in a 1980s eBay rotovap he washed thoroughly after it arrived filthy and smelling of carbon tetrachloride. Lime distilled with gin was infinitely better than lime distilled alone, because ethanol holds volatiles far better than water. Acids and sugars do not distill, so he had to add lime acids back. Lime juice has citric and malic acid in a 2:1 ratio with a pinch of succinic acid. Citric alone tastes of lemon; malic alone tastes like green-apple candy; together they taste of lime. Tonic makers use only citric, which he finds criminal. The tiny succinic addition, a couple of hundredths of a percent, is the real secret: bitter, salty and unpleasant alone, it improves the whole in minute amounts. (His 2007 method took five or so rounds of tasting and adjusting, with the mix chilled in the same chiller as the rotovap condenser.)
He also distilled his own gins from Thai basil, cilantro, roasted oranges, cucumber and juniper, which left him with real respect for professional distillers, so he left gin to them. His father drank old-school Bombay, which he likes better than Sapphire, but he reaches for Tanqueray.
Clarified lime and his recipe
Distilled lime essence keeps no better than fresh juice, and he could do only about a litre an hour. Clarifying lime juice freed him from the rotovap and let him make huge volumes for events. To chill batches at the bar, he bought a Randell FX fridge/freezer set to -7 degrees C (about 20 F), for several hours before carbonating and for holding the drinks in service. If you drink your G&Ts the same day, add the clarified lime juice before carbonating. To keep them longer, clarify fresh lime juice every day, never compromise on that, and add it at service; the small amount of uncarbonated juice does not hurt the bubbles.
Gin and Tonic (one 165 ml drink at 15.4 percent alcohol, 4.9 g/100 ml sugar, 0.41 percent acid): a full 1 3/4 ounces (53.5 ml) Tanqueray, a short half ounce (12.5 ml) of quinine or cinchona syrup, a short 3 ounces (87 ml) filtered water, 1 or 2 drops of saline and 3/8 ounce (11.25 ml) of clarified lime juice (6 percent acid). Chill at -5 to -10 degrees C, carbonate at 42 psi without the lime juice and add it as you pour into a chilled flute. Carbonated with the lime, serve it that day; without, it keeps indefinitely.
Tonic Water Two Ways (34 ounces, 1,021 ml, at 8.8 g/100 ml sugar and 0.75 percent acid, on the dry side): 4 3/4 ounces (142.5 ml) quinine or cinchona syrup, 4 1/4 ounces (127.5 ml) clarified lime juice or premade lime acid (6 percent acid) or, without premade, 5.1 grams of citric acid and 2.6 grams of malic acid with the tiniest pinch of succinic acid dissolved in 4 ounces (120 ml) of water, 20 drops (1 ml) of saline, and 25 ounces (750 ml) of filtered water. Combine, chill and carbonate at 40 to 45 psi. The lime juice must be fresh; the acid versions keep indefinitely but are not quite as good.
The bottle-strength experiment
He once tried a gin-and-tonic shot at the strength of the gin itself, by distilling a litre of Tanqueray with half a litre of lime juice down to 700 ml (about 67 percent alcohol), leaving room under 300 ml to add lime acid, syrup, quinine and salt and still end at 47.3 percent; chilled to -20 degrees C and carbonated at 50 psi. It worked only between -16 and -20 degrees C, because cold dulls sugar far more than acid, so a shot needs more sugar at -20 than at -7. Colder was painful on the tongue, warmer tasted sickly sweet and overly alcoholic. A mere 4 degrees of leeway, and people who stop to talk let it spoil in their hands. The experiment turned him off strong carbonated drinks, and he now serves lower-alcohol ones that are more temperature-resilient, less cloying and less stupefying. It is a stunt he will not repeat.
Looking for a tonic substitute
His latest challenge is a drink with the feel of a G&T but no tonic, so no lime and no quinine, just because it is a challenge. His two best candidates:
- Schisandra berries, the Chinese five-flavour berry: tart and bitter, a bit sweet and peppery. Avoid dry ones that look like peppercorns and look for a nice red colour. Direct infusion in gin works best so far, giving refreshing G&T-plus-pepper drinks, but results vary with the product, so he has no recipe.
- Camu camu, a South American fruit. At a 2012 lecture in Bogota, a bright red camu camu puree struck him as the perfect replacer: the bitterness of tonic, the acidity of lime and a faintly Christmasy spiciness. He clarified it with Pectinex Ultra SP-L and a small desktop centrifuge, mixed it with gin, sugar and salt, and carbonated it for a fantastic drink. A later Peruvian puree was yellow, which suggests a different fruit or cultivar, an unripe harvest or skins removed in processing, and it lacked the spice and the bitter bite. Someone in Colombia has this wonderful ingredient, he says, and should use it.