Measuring CO2 in a Drink, Champagne Loss, Foam and How Bubbles Form

Carbonation and Nitro, Production and Science, Techniques and Methods

Measuring CO2 in a Drink, Champagne Loss, Foam and How Bubbles Form

Weigh the bottle before and after to know how much CO2 went in. Dave Arnold also shows how much a pour loses (11.5 to 8.4 g/l in champagne), why foam control is nine-tenths of good carbonation, how bubbles form like balloons, and what a volume of CO2 is.

  • Based onLiquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold

At a glance

Weigh the bottle before and after to know how much CO2 went in. Dave Arnold also shows how much a pour loses, why foam control is nine-tenths of good carbonation, how bubbles form like balloons, and what a volume of CO2 is.

  1. Weigh the carbonator bottle without the cap before and after carbonating to learn the grams of CO2 added.
  2. A careful pour of champagne drops CO2 from 11.5 to 9.8 g/l, a careless one to 8.4 g/l, and tall glasses lose less through the surface.
  3. A bubble needs a nucleation site, because a clean liquid in a perfectly clean glass forms none, and one volume of CO2 is roughly 2 g/l.

Measuring the CO2 you add

The easiest way to measure how much CO2 you have put into a drink is to weigh it. Weigh the uncarbonated liquid on a scale in the carbonator bottle without the cap, carbonate, and weigh the bottle again with the cap still off. The added weight is the CO2 you dissolved, and the figure should be converted to grams per litre. In his example, 4.3 grams went into 500 ml. The cap must be off so the scale does not register the weight of compressed CO2 inside the bottle.

Carbonation lost in the pour

CO2 in the bottle is worth nothing if it never reaches your tongue: what counts is what is in the glass. The champagne physicist Gerard Liger-Belair (a real job, he notes, and you are too late to get it) has studied CO2 loss in champagne closely. Uncorking a fridge-cold bottle and pouring carefully down the side of an inclined glass, the best case, lowers the CO2 from 11.5 grams per litre to 9.8. That loss is probably a good thing, he says, since 11.5 g/l is too intense. Carelessly pouring the same champagne into the same glass cuts it to 8.4 g/l, his lower limit for good carbonation in a fresh glass of young champagne. Open the same bottle at room temperature and you lose a couple more grams per litre. Open it carelessly so that it gushes, or fobs as the soda trade says, and the loss is far worse.

Nine-tenths of good carbonation is foam control.

Two routes for CO2 to escape

  • From the surface. The glass controls this. The less drink surface is exposed per unit of volume, the less CO2 is lost per unit of time. That is why flutes and other tall glasses suit carbonated drinks, and why you should fill them high if the drink will sit a while: more volume for the same exposed surface.
  • Through bubbles. This is harder to control. A perfectly clear carbonated liquid poured into a perfectly clean, smooth glass gives no bubbles at all, because forming a bubble in a pure liquid is extremely hard.

How a bubble forms

Bubbles in a drink inflate the way a balloon does: the CO2 pressure in the drink is higher than in the bubble, so the bubble blows up, while the surface tension of the surrounding liquid acts like the rubber and resists inflation. And like balloons, the smaller a bubble is, the harder it is to inflate. There is a critical bubble radius, set by the liquid’s surface tension and the CO2 pressure in the drink: any bubble smaller than that is crushed back to nothing, and any larger tends to grow. You cannot simply raise the pressure to start bubbles, because it would take hundreds of times more CO2 than ordinary bubbly drinks hold to form them spontaneously.

What you need are nucleation sites, anything in or touching the liquid that lets bubbles form (see the article on the three Cs of carbonation for how to limit them).

What a volume of CO2 means

Soda literature quotes CO2 in volumes. Avogadro worked out in the 1800s that equal volumes of gas at equal temperature and pressure hold equal numbers of molecules, whatever the molecules weigh. Avogadro’s number, 6.022 x 10^23, converts between atomic mass units and grams: a CO2 molecule is 44.01 amu, so 6.022 x 10^23 of them weigh exactly 44.01 grams, a quantity called a mole. (The page prints 6.023 x 10^23 once and 6.022 x 10^23 elsewhere; the usual value is the latter.) One mole of any gas at standard temperature and pressure fills 22.4 litres, so a mole of CO2 weighs 44.01 grams and occupies 22.4 litres. One volume of CO2 is the mass of CO2 that fills a given volume at standard conditions: 44.01 grams divided by 22.4 litres, roughly 2 g/l, the conversion used in the article on how bubbles work.

Quotations

In the author's words

  • Nine-tenths of good carbonation is foam control.

    Page 297

Sources

Where this comes from

Written for this guide from the Carbonation chapter of Liquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold (pages 296 and 297); the facts and the figures are the author's, the wording is ours, and the quotation is given with its page.

More articles

Keep reading