Acids and Salt at the Bar: Lime Acid, Champagne Acid and Saline

Bar Fundamentals, Ingredients and Sourcing, Production and Science

Acids and Salt at the Bar: Lime Acid, Champagne Acid and Saline

Acid is in almost every cocktail, and different acids taste different alone and in combination. Dave Arnold explains the common acids, how fresh lime juice should be, his acid blends and why a drop of saline lifts a drink.

  • Based onLiquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold

At a glance

Acid is in almost every cocktail, and different acids taste different alone and in combination. Dave Arnold explains the common acids, how fresh lime juice should be, his lime and champagne acid blends and why a drop of saline lifts a drink.

  1. The tongue senses the amount of acid, not the pH, so a gram of citric acid can be swapped for malic or tartaric and the acidity stays close.
  2. Lime juice is about 4 percent citric and 2 percent malic acid, so Lime Acid is 4 g citric and 2 g malic in 94 g of water, and juice a few hours old often beats very fresh juice.
  3. Champagne Acid is 1:1 tartaric and lactic acid, and a drop of 20 percent saline, kept below the threshold of taste, lifts any drink with fruit, chocolate or coffee.

Tasting acid

It is a rare cocktail with no acid, even if it is hidden in vermouth or another wine-based ingredient. Almost all the common cocktail acids are sold in pure form at home-brew shops. Dave Arnold points out that acids are molecules that release free hydrogen ions in water, and scientists measure this as pH, but your tongue does not work like a pH meter and does not sense how acidic something is; it senses how many acid molecules are present, called titratable acidity. So pH meters are useless for cocktails, and you can swap a gram of citric acid for a gram of malic or tartaric: it will taste different, but the acidity will be close. In his book acidity is a percentage per unit volume, and 1 percent means that a litre of juice contains 10 grams of acid.

How fresh should lime juice be

Arnold ran taste tests of lime juice at different ages, in cocktails and in limeade: 24, 8, 5, 3 and 2 hours old, and fresh. Day-old juice always lost, but surprisingly, juice several hours old usually beat very fresh juice. The tasters were mostly professional American bartenders, who typically juice limes at the start of a shift and so serve juice that is several hours old. His colleague Don Lee ran the same test with European bartenders, who juice to order, and they tended to choose the fresh juice. Best may simply be what you are used to.

Lemons and limes

Lemon and lime juice, the two most common acids at the bar, are both about 6 percent acid. Lemon’s acid is almost pure citric acid, and lime juice is about 4 percent citric and 2 percent malic with a trace of succinic acid, which tastes terrible alone, bitter, metallic and bloody, but in tiny amounts improves lime juice. They are roughly interchangeable in quantity, though malic acid makes lime’s acidity linger longer. Unlike grapefruit, orange and apple juice, which keep for a couple of days or more, lemon and lime juice must be used the day they are made; lime is the most fragile, changing as soon as it is juiced, and he likes it best after it has rested a couple of hours. How you juice matters too. At 6 percent they are concentrated, and a typical sour needs only three-quarters of an ounce. Most other juices are not acidic enough, so he makes acid blends that mimic lime juice.

The common acids

  • Citric: the main acid of lemon; tastes like lemon, clean, hits hard and fast, then fades quickly.
  • Malic: the main acid of apples; green-apple candy; its flavour lingers longer than citric.
  • Tartaric: the main acid of grapes; sour-grape candy.
  • Acetic: vinegar, the only common food acid that is aromatic; a minor acid, especially in bitters and savoury cocktails.
  • Lactic: from fermentation; reminiscent of sauerkraut, pickles, cheese and salami, yet agreeable in cocktails.
  • Phosphoric: the only inorganic one here; extremely strong and dry; with citric it is the acid of colas; not available from home-brew shops, and he rarely uses it.
  • Ascorbic: vitamin C; little flavour or acidity, used as an antioxidant to stop juices and fruit turning brown, and often confused with citric acid.

Mixtures taste unlike single acids. Citric acid tastes like lemon and malic like apple, but together they taste like lime. Tartaric tastes like grape and lactic like sauerkraut, but together they are the characteristic acid of champagne.

Three recipes

  • Lime Acid. A stand-in for lime juice, never a replacement for the fruit but useful to give fruit a little more acidity: 94 grams of filtered water, 4 grams of citric acid, 2 grams of malic acid and 0.04 gram of succinic acid for authenticity, which can be left out. Stir until dissolved.
  • Lime Acid Orange. Orange juice has about 0.8 percent citric acid, not enough for a proper sour. Rather than buy sour oranges, he corrects a glut of ordinary oranges, whose peel went to garnish, to the acid profile of lime juice: 1 litre of fresh orange juice with 32 grams of citric acid and 20 grams of malic acid. Careful when juicing oranges, because some, including many navels, turn bitter after the juice sits. His Dr. J tastes like an orange Julius.
  • Champagne Acid. Grapes’ main acids are tartaric and malic, but champagne usually goes through malolactic fermentation, which turns malic into lactic acid; champagnes that skip it keep a green-apple note. So his blend is 1:1 tartaric and lactic: 94 grams of warm water, 3 grams of tartaric acid and 3 grams of powdered lactic acid, stirred until dissolved. It tends to crystallise on standing, so just shake it. It is surprisingly versatile, used in carbonated drinks or whenever he wants a bit of champagne feeling, but rarely as the only acid in a drink.

Salt

Salt is the secret ingredient in almost all my cocktails.

Any cocktail with fruit, chocolate or coffee benefits from a pinch, and he rarely wants a drink to taste salty: the salt should be below the threshold of taste. To see for yourself, divide a cocktail between two glasses and add a pinch of salt to one. At home a pinch will do. At the bar he uses a saline solution of 20 grams of salt in 80 millilitres of water, a 20 percent solution, and a drop or two is all it takes to make a cocktail pop.

Quotations

In the author's words

  • Salt is the secret ingredient in almost all my cocktails.

    Page 61

Sources

Where this comes from

Written for this guide from the Acids and Salt sections of the Ingredients chapter of Liquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold (pages 58 to 61; page 62 was not scanned); the facts, the amounts and the recipes are the author's, the wording is ours, and the quotation is given with its page.

More articles

Keep reading