Carbonating at Home: Bottle Cap and Tank, Sodastream and iSi Whipper

Bar Fundamentals, Carbonation and Nitro, Techniques and Methods

Carbonating at Home: Bottle Cap and Tank, Sodastream and iSi Whipper

Dave Arnold's three ways to carbonate cocktails: the carbonator cap on a CO2 tank, the Sodastream with its two-drink rule, and the iSi cream whipper as a last resort, plus water choice and a home seltzer tap.

  • Based onLiquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold

At a glance

Dave Arnold's three ways to carbonate cocktails: the carbonator cap on a CO2 tank, the Sodastream with its two-drink rule, and the iSi cream whipper as a last resort. The article also covers water choice and a home seltzer tap.

  1. The cap and tank rig costs under 200 dollars: a 20-pound tank, a regulator set to about 42 psi, a hose, a ball-lock connector and a carbonator cap on a plastic bottle.
  2. Fill the bottle two-thirds to three-quarters full of very cold drink, shake while connected, vent and repeat three times, rest, and fluff the bottle after every pour.
  3. With a Sodastream always carbonate exactly two 165 ml drinks, never fill past a third, and keep pulp out.

Technique one: bottle, cap and tank

The easiest method, and the one Dave Arnold uses at home and at the bar, is a special adapter that hooks a plastic soda bottle to a large CO2 tank. It is simple, fairly cheap and gives amazing, predictable results for pennies a drink. The whole rig, tank with gas, regulator, hose, fittings, caps and bottles, should cost under $200.

  • Tank. A large tank beats cartridges or minibottles because the gas is far cheaper. Sizes are by pounds of CO2: he uses 20-pound tanks at home and at the bar and 5-pounders on the road. A 20-pounder just fits an under-counter cabinet and carbonates hundreds of gallons. Buy one rather than rent (a new empty 20-pounder was under $100), and the local welding shop swaps it for a full one and charges for the gas, about $1 to $2 a pound. Chain it upright, keep it from extreme heat and learn the basic CO2 safety rules first.
  • Regulator. It drops the tank’s roughly 850 psi at room temperature to the 30 to 45 psi used for carbonating, and lets you change the pressure easily. At home an inexpensive 0 to 60 psi Taprite regulator costs about $50; at the bar he uses heavy-duty ones with a cage over the gauge, the most fragile part. There are two gauges, tank and output, and the tank gauge says nothing about what is left, because most of the CO2 is liquid and the gauge reads full until the tank is nearly empty. Only the weight and the sound of liquid sloshing tell you.
  • Ball-lock connector. A reinforced hose joins the regulator to a ball-lock gas connector, designed in the 1950s for 5-gallon soda kegs. Bag-in-box won the soda market, surplus kegs and connectors flooded to home brewers, and some of them made a cap that attaches the connector to ordinary soda bottles, the carbonator cap, to keep small quantities of beer fizzy. Cocktail people adopted it quickly. A cap costs about $15 and lasts many hundreds of cycles, as do the bottles.

Carbonating step by step

  1. Open the CO2 and set the pressure; for most cocktails he uses 42 psi.
  2. Fill a soda bottle two-thirds to three-quarters full of very, very cold drink. At the bar a Randell FX freezer chills it to exactly the temperature he wants; at home leave it in the freezer until it gets syrupy (high alcohol) or just forms ice crystals (lower alcohol), which melt as you carbonate. Liquid nitrogen or dry ice can chill it too, but never let either into the bottle: explosion hazard.
  3. Squeeze all the extra air out of the bottle and screw on the cap. Pull up the ring of the connector, press it hard onto the cap and release. The bottle inflates quickly.
  4. With the gas connected, shake as though your life depends on it; you will hear the gas go in. Do not hold the bottle upside down, or cocktail gets into the gas line.
  5. Pop off the connector and crack the cap to let the drink foam, without unscrewing it all the way. When the foam dies, carbonate and foam again, then a third time.
  6. Rest at least 30 seconds, up to a minute or two, until the drink looks clear, because it is the bubbles in the drink, not the foam on top, that matter. Open very gently to pour, at an angle.
  7. After pouring, squeeze out excess gas, recap and hit the bottle with CO2 again, which he calls fluffing. Keep the temperature right and fluff after every pour, and the last drink will be as good as the first.

His results are best with bottles two-thirds to three-quarters full: fuller is hard to defoam, less full hard to purge of air.

Technique two: Sodastream

Do not fill the bottle past one-third of the way to the fill line, about 11 ounces (330 ml), which makes two drinks, to leave room for foam. At that level the wand is not submerged, but the CO2 spray still makes tiny bubbles; you press the button more times and waste more gas. You cannot make less than two drinks, because the CO2 will not inject well into a low fill.

In one sentence, the secret of the Sodastream is always carbonate exactly two 5½-ounce (165-ml) drinks.
  • Vent to atmospheric pressure and recarbonate several times, as with every method. Release pressure carefully, able to stop at once, because foam can reach the relief valve with surprising speed; practise on plain water. Never let foam rise above the bottle top or into the valve, and unscrew only a little at a time.
  • Never put pulp in the system. Let the drink settle after the last cycle before the final venting, and keep it supercold, almost frozen.
  • The instructions suit most models, but not the glass one, which works differently and has to be hacked, and makes him nervous.
  • Advantages: small footprint, easy, everywhere. Disadvantage: far more CO2 spent than with a proper tank, because wine and cocktails use much more than water.

Water for carbonation

Good seltzer starts with good water: if it tastes bad flat, it tastes worse with bubbles. His favourite base is New York City tap water, soft with no off flavours. Minerals add taste and usually make a drink taste less carbonated than it is; he likes Apollinaris, Gerolsteiner and Vichy occasionally, but for refreshment prefers soft-water seltzer. Chlorine tastes poisonous in seltzer. If your pipes are lead-free you can drive it off with heat: start with hot water and cool it, or heat and cool cold water.

Technique three: iSi whipper

His least favourite common method, used only when nothing else is available. A whipped-cream maker makes better bubbles than the seltzer-style siphon, which he never uses, but its 7.5-gram CO2 cartridges are costly (up to a dollar each, at least two per drink), and you cannot control the pressure, only add or not add another cartridge.

  • Chill the whipper in the freezer first, since the steel warms the drink, and add an ice cube or two.
  • Fill about one-third, never over half, and keep fill levels the same, because the pressure and so the carbonation depend on the fill line.
  • Check that the valve is clean (it clogs if you use the whipper for infusions) and the main gasket is in place, or you waste a cartridge.
  • Add the first cartridge and shake hard, then hold it upright and use the handle to vent the air and blow air off the nucleation sites. If drink sprays out, release and wait a second. Add a second cartridge, shake, let it settle and vent slowly.

The whipper’s one advantage is nitrous oxide, which is sweet and adds body and liveliness without a carbonated taste; it suits coffee and chocolate drinks, not milk, which foams far too much. For a mixed gas, carbonate with two CO2 cartridges and finish with one nitrous cartridge in very cold ice water. His favourite bubbly water is 80 percent CO2 and 20 percent N2O at 45 psi in ice water.

Bubbles on draft

At home he has seltzer on draft from a 5.3-litre McCann commercial carbonator on his water supply. Bars have poor soda from poor filtration, chilling and dispensing, not from poor carbonators.

  • Filtration: a dedicated filter takes out chlorine and sediment before the carbonator.
  • Chilling: a carbonator carbonates room-temperature water at about 100 psi. A cold plate, an aluminium block with stainless tubing in ice, chills it and slows it so it does not spray when dispensed. One circuit is too short, so he runs the seltzer through two circuits in series.
  • Dispensing: use a CMBecker premix soda tap, whose pressure compensation eases the drink from high to low pressure with minimal bubble loss, and never a beer or picnic tap. His has run over fourteen years without trouble.

For draft sodas or cocktails he warns of perils: only drinks that want little carbonation and can be served warmer, around 2 degrees C (36 F).

Quotations

In the author's words

  • in one sentence, the secret of the Sodastream is always carbonate exactly two 5½-ounce (165-ml) drinks

    Page 311

Sources

Where this comes from

Written for this guide from the techniques section of the Carbonation chapter of Liquid Intelligence by Dave Arnold (pages 302 to 307, 310 to 314; pages 308 and 309 were not scanned and are not used); the facts, the amounts and the methods are the author's, the wording is ours, and the quotation is given with its page.

More articles

Keep reading