Get out and taste
Dave Arnold says this is a great time for apples, with interesting varieties within everyone’s reach. Away from good growers you can buy specialty apples online; in apple country farmers’ markets show more varieties every year. His advice is to get out and taste. The bibliography lists key apple references, but they are no substitute for your mouth. Bring a knife: slicing off a piece of flesh and skin tells you more than biting a whole fruit, especially if you are tasting dozens and want to spare your gums.
Texture does not matter for juice
Erase your perception of texture and focus only on how the juice tastes.
Texture matters only indirectly, he explains, because America accepts only crunchy apples, which has pushed out whole groups of potentially good cocktail apples. We have lost the ability to tell crumbly from mealy. A mealy apple was crunchy once and has been stored too long, and is bad. A crumbly apple was never crunchy when ripe, and is entirely different; accept the beauty of difference.
It affects juice quality because growers of heirloom varieties know you will buy only crunchy apples and often pick them viciously underripe, since mature fruit would be too soft to sell. Underripe apples are sad: little varietal flavour, flat, not yet sweet, tasting like acid bombs and full of unconverted starch. Early-season apples suffer most, as they are light in flavour to begin with, have a very short season and go mushy faster than any others, and growers are hard to persuade to pick them ripe. As cocktail people we do not care about texture, since we are only making juice, but we still pay the price. His request: tell your growers that if they pick ripe apples, you will buy lots.
Learning to ignore texture is hard at first, so practise. When you cut an apple, feel how the knife moves: an underripe one feels like slicing a hard potato, and you can see starch on the cut face before you taste it. Avoid these.
Taste the blush side and the shade side
Apples on one tree ripen at different rates, and sun exposure and position on the branch change the flavour. Look in a bin or on a tree for the two most differently coloured apples of a variety, even in apples that stay green, whose colour darkens or blushes as they ripen: tasting both shows the range of flavours that variety is likely to have. On a single fruit, taste the side farthest from the blush first, then the blush side, which will be richer, sweeter and more sun-kissed. The juice of the whole apple lands between the two. Then take only the apples that meet your needs: buy two of each interesting variety at a market, taste them on the spot and buy what you need. Apple juice freezes well, so if you find one you love, buy a lot, juice it and freeze it.
Sugar and acid
- Apples that do well in cocktails tend to be high in both sugar and acid. Low-sugar apples are rarely good because they are mostly underripe and so have little flavour as well.
- High-acid juice is good because the cocktail then needs no other acid. Low-acid apples can be improved with straight malic acid, lemon or lime juice or even an acidic ingredient like vermouth, but he prefers apples that need little adjusting so the pure apple flavour shows.
- Commercial and hard-cider producers quote varieties by sugar-to-acid ratio, one number that tells the balance, with the sugar level, usually in Brix, giving overall taste strength. Few people can measure acidity (pH meters will not do), but benchmarks for many varieties are online and useful for choosing what to test.
- For cocktails he likes a ratio of about 13 to 15: 13 is tart, 15 pleasantly acidic. For reference, Granny Smith is about 14 and the low-acid, fairly sweet Gala about 21.
- Juice should be above 11 Brix to be useful, and is better around 14 or 15, as sweet as or sweeter than soda.
Avoid tired apples
In a market, apples past their prime no longer feel hard and may be shrivelled. In an orchard, feel them: greasy skin signals overripeness, because the natural waxy coating gets greasier as they ripen (the test is no use in a grocery store, where washing may have removed the natural coating and put another on). Cut a suspect apple open: many overripe apples show water core, a wet look as if frozen and thawed, and are usually, but not always, softer than they should be.
Overripe or over-stored apples are no good to eat, but mildly overripe ones can make an interesting cocktail ingredient. They lose acid, so they always need more acid correction than ripe ones. They can also develop intriguing perfumed floral aromas, as ethylene gas triggers volatile esters; in small amounts these esters can be fabulous, in excess the apples smell of solvent. They are also very fugitive, so beware if you want to capture them.